((My personal theory is that his monk-senses are warning him that Emiya has an H-scene with her in all three routes. I'd hate her too, if Emiya was my crush.))
Of course it would. It would explain why I dislike her so much for reasons I don't even know. And it might explain why you think she's a good person - I'm not denying that there must be good witches somewhere...
Page 5 of 9